Summary: Four steps for working through a disagreement at work when both sides have a good point.
You suggest replacing the weekly check-in with written updates. Most of the meeting goes to updates people could read in a few minutes.
Your colleague wants to keep it. Last week, the check-in was where they found out the figures they needed on Tuesday wouldn’t be ready until Thursday. A quick conversation helped them figure out what they could start in the meantime.
Both of you have a good point. Use STEP to work through the disagreement and decide what to do next.
S — State the choice
Say what you see differently, then check that you’re talking about the same choice. This gives you a clear question to work on together.
What you could say:
“I’m suggesting we move the routine updates to writing. Which parts of the check-in do you think we still need to do live?”
T — Talk through both concerns
Give a concrete example of why your option makes sense, and ask for one from your colleague. Use those examples to work out what any next step needs to accomplish.
What you could say:
“Last week we spent most of the meeting sharing updates we could have read. The conversation about the figures helped you adjust your plan. How can we give people some time back and still catch those issues early?”
E — Evaluate an option
Suggest something specific. Talk through where it would help, what it would ask of people, and what could still go wrong. Adjust the option if one of the concerns is still open.
What you could say:
“What if we post updates ahead of time and use 15 minutes to sort out anything that needs a conversation? How would we catch something like the delay with the figures?”
Your colleague points out that nobody saw the problem until they heard both updates. You could ask people to include what they’re waiting for and when they need it. You’d save meeting time, and people would need to read the updates and flag issues before the check-in.
P — Plan the next step
If you can try the option, agree on who’ll do what, how long you’ll try it, and what you’ll check before deciding whether to keep it.
What you could say:
“I’ll ask everyone to post their updates by Monday afternoon. Let’s try the shorter check-in for two weeks. Then we can see whether it saved time and whether anyone still found out too late that their work was held up.”
If you still disagree, name the concern that’s open and decide what would help you move forward. You might check a fact together, revise the option, or ask whoever owns the decision to make the call with both concerns in view.




